Morning coffee, notebook and pencil on a kitchen table in warm golden light

The Five-Minute Review: My Checklist for Anything AI Writes

In my last post, Looks Good to Me: Why I Still Read Everything AI Writes, I wrote about why a real person needs to read AI-written work before it goes out. A few people asked me the obvious next question: “Okay, but what am I actually supposed to look for?”

Fair question. That post was the why. This one is the how.

Below is the review I run on anything an AI tool helps me write, whether it’s an email, a service page, a Google review reply or a social post. It takes about five minutes. It isn’t fancy, and that’s on purpose. A checklist only helps if you actually use it on a busy Tuesday.

Why a checklist and not just “read it carefully”

“Read it carefully” sounds good, but when you’re tired or behind, careful reading turns into skimming. Your eyes slide over smooth sentences, and AI writes very smooth sentences. That’s exactly why mistakes get through.

A checklist gives you specific things to hunt for. You’re not asking “does this seem fine?” You’re asking “is the phone number right?” and “did I just promise something I can’t deliver?” Those questions are much harder to skip past.

I use AI every day for drafts and research. It saves me real time. And I still read and approve everything myself before it goes out. This checklist is how I keep that step quick enough that I don’t drop it.

1. Facts: is everything true?

Start here, because this is where AI is most likely to quietly fill a gap with something that sounds right but isn’t.

  • Names. Your business name, your staff, products, places. Spelled right and current.
  • Prices. Every number with a dollar sign. Check it against what you actually charge today.
  • Hours. Including holiday hours and anything seasonal.
  • Dates. Event dates, deadlines, “this Friday” style references. Make sure the day and date actually match.
  • Service areas. Do you really serve every neighborhood or town it lists? AI likes to be generous here.
  • Links. Click every one. Make sure it works and goes where you meant it to go, not to an old page or a near miss.

If you can’t verify something in a minute or two, cut it. A shorter accurate piece beats a longer one with a wrong detail.

2. Promises: could you back it up to a customer’s face?

AI tools tend to lean toward confident, upbeat language. That’s fine until it turns into a promise you didn’t mean to make.

  • Look for guarantees. Words like “guaranteed,” “always,” “never,” “every time” and “results in.” Are those actually true for your business?
  • Look for “best” claims. “The best in Pittsburgh,” “the fastest,” “the only.” Can you prove it? If not, take it out.
  • Check turnaround times and offers. If it says “same-day service” or “20% off,” is that real and current?
  • Run the face test. Picture a customer reading this line back to you at the counter. If you’d feel even a little uncomfortable, rewrite it.

Here’s a good rule: if you wouldn’t say it out loud to someone you respect, don’t publish it.

3. Voice: does it sound like you?

This one is easy to skip and it matters a lot. People can tell when something sounds like it came from the same tool everyone else uses.

  • Read it out loud. Really, out loud. You’ll hear the clunky and unnatural parts right away.
  • Ask “would I say this?” If you’d never use a word in conversation, swap it for one you would.
  • Cut the filler. AI loves openers and phrases that take up space without saying anything. Watch for things like “look no further,” “elevate your experience,” “seamless,” “whether you’re a first-timer or a seasoned pro,” and “we’re passionate about.” Delete them and see if the sentence still works. It usually works better.
  • Trim the length. AI drafts often run long. If a paragraph says the same thing twice, keep the better half.

You don’t need to be a writer for this. You just need to sound like yourself.

4. Fit: is it right for who’s reading it?

A piece can be accurate and sound like you and still miss the mark if it’s aimed at the wrong person or asks them to do the wrong thing.

  • Right audience. Is this written for the people who will actually see it? A review reply should talk to that one customer. A service page should talk to someone deciding whether to call you.
  • Right call to action. Does it tell readers what to do next, and is it the thing you actually want? Call, book, reply, visit. Pick one main ask.
  • Nothing confusing. Any jargon, vague terms or sentences you had to read twice? Your reader will have the same trouble.
  • Nothing misleading. Even if each sentence is technically true, would the overall impression be off? If someone could walk away believing something that isn’t so, fix it.

The checklist to print or save

Here’s the whole thing in one place. Copy it into a note on your phone or tape it next to your desk.

  1. Names are spelled right and current.
  2. Prices match what I charge today.
  3. Hours, dates and days of the week are correct.
  4. Service areas are ones I actually serve.
  5. Every link is clicked, working and going to the right page.
  6. No guarantees or “best” claims I can’t back up.
  7. Offers and turnaround times are real and current.
  8. I’d be comfortable if a customer quoted any line back to me.
  9. I read it out loud and it sounds like me.
  10. Generic filler phrases are cut.
  11. It’s written for the person who will actually read it.
  12. There’s one clear next step, and it’s the right one.
  13. Nothing could confuse or mislead someone.

Thirteen items sounds like a lot, but most take a few seconds each. Once it’s a habit, you’ll fly through it.

Match your effort to the stakes

Not everything needs the same level of attention. Being careful doesn’t mean being slow everywhere. Here’s how I split it up:

  • Quick skim: internal notes, brainstorm lists, rough outlines, drafts only you or your team will see. Glance at it, make sure nothing is way off, and move on. This is where AI saves you the most time.
  • Full checklist: anything public or anything going to your whole list. Emails, website pages, social posts, ads and review replies. Run all thirteen items. One mistake sent to everyone is one mistake multiplied by everyone.
  • Slow read: anything in a sensitive area, like health, money, housing or legal topics. Run the full checklist, then read it again slowly. In these areas a single wrong word can mislead someone or cause real trouble. If you’re not sure something is accurate or appropriate, leave it out or check with the right professional before it goes live.

If you’re ever unsure which bucket something falls into, bump it up a level. An extra two minutes costs a lot less than cleaning up a public mistake.

A few habits that make it stick

  • Review before you schedule, not after. Once something is queued up, it’s easy to forget about.
  • Take a short break first. Even five minutes away from a draft helps you see it with fresh eyes.
  • Keep a running list of fixes. If you keep cutting the same phrases or correcting the same detail, add it to the instructions you give your AI tool. Your drafts will get better over time.
  • Own the final call. The tool helps you write. You decide what goes out with your name on it.

Let’s connect

AI can be a great help in a small business, especially when there’s a person keeping an eye on what goes out. If you’d like to talk through how to use these tools in your own marketing, or you just want a second set of eyes on how you’re doing it now, I’d be glad to hear from you. Let’s connect.

Tags :

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn